Touch-evoked Neuropathic Pain in Clinical Practice: A Case Series of 1000 Paradoxical Painful Hypo-aesthesia.
[Citation] : Spicher, C.J. (2016). Editorial : Touch-evoked Neuropathic Pain in Clinical Practice: A Case Series of 1000 Paradoxical Painful Hypo-aesthesia. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 13(2), 52-57.
Claude J SPICHER[1]
“In the present study, 100 % of the Static Mechancial Allodynia (SMA) territories (n=63) investigated and treated on the skin of 43 patients completely disappeared, replaced by an underlying hypoaesthetic territory, which was then treated at a later stage. This clinically highly significant result was obtained using the Distant Vibrotactile Counter-Stimulation (DVCS) treatment: weekly in therapy and daily at home by application of tactile stimuli eight times a day for 1 minute.” (Spicher et al., 2008a). We concluded that SMA is a paradoxical painful to touch hypo-aesthesia.
Since the 1st of July 2004, these data were collected and recorded by somatosensory therapists of pain at the Somatosensory Rehabilitation Centre (Fribourg, Switzerland).
The 27h of May 2016, we observed for the 1000th times the same phenomenon (Table I):
When the hyper-sensitivity to touch – allodynia – disappears, an underlying tactile hypo-aesthesia is revealed.
In other words, the Certified Somatosensory Therapists of Pain (CSTP®) would say: “When the allodynography becomes negative, it is the moment to map a positive secondary aesthesiography. None of the SMA territory – represented by the allodynography - becomes immediately normosensitive at the end of the DVCS treatment”.
Basic knowledge
Treatment of Touch-evoked Neuropathic Pain:
1) To postulate which branch of the cutaneous nerve affected is damaged.
2) To define a specific zone of the skin where DVCS should be applied eight times a day for 1 minute - or less long - at home.
3) To delineate a specific zone of the skin to be avoided as much as possible: STOP sensitization by temporarily NOT TOUCHING, if possible the painful territory.
In the present case series, 714 neuropathic pain patients who presented in total 1000 static mechanical allodynia completed their DVCS treatment (Table II).
This phenomenon can be consistently observed in each cutaneous distribution territory of the 240 cutaneous branches of the human body (Spicher et al., 2013) in 10 cutaneous departments (Table III).
We conclude that one of the aetiologies of tactile allodynia is Aβ neurofibers lesion of a cutaneous branch.
Part of these results have been already published (Clément-Favre, 2011 ; Della Casa et al., 2010 ; Desfoux et al., 2008 ; Desfoux, et al., 2009 ; Grass et al., 2008 ; Mathis et al., 2006 ; Mathis et al., 2007 ; Spicher et al., 2008a, 2008b, 2015, 2016) and will be published in the further years. Numerous Case Reports have been as well published with the same observation in Belgium (Behar, 2013), in Switzerland (Duchesne, 2014), in France (Landreau, 2010; Langlois, 2014 ; Parneix, 2015) and in Canada (Calva, 2013 ; Packham, 2013).
References
Behar, E. (2013). Fait clinique illustrant la diminution rapide des douleurs neuropathiques d’une névralgie crurale intermittente avec allodynie mécanique. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 10(1), 29-34.
Available (5/28/2016): http://blog.unifr.ch/e-NewsSomatosensoryRehabilitation/wp-content/uploads/Le-News-1011.pdf#page=29
Calva, V. (2013). Névralgie fémoro-poplitée avec allodynie mécanique, suite à une lésion cutanée profonde greffée, traitée par la rééducation sensitive de la douleur. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 10(2), 64-69.
Available (5/28/2016): http://blog.unifr.ch/e-NewsSomatosensoryRehabilitation/wp-content/uploads/Le-News-10_2_.pdf#page=11
Clément-Favre, S. (2011). Fait clinique : Névralgie dorso-intercostale incessante avec allodynie mécanique. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 8(3), 154-157.
Available (5/28/2016): http://blog.unifr.ch/e-NewsSomatosensoryRehabilitation/wp-content/uploads/Le-News-8_3.pdf#page=52
Della Casa, R., Coales, K., de Raemy, X. & Spicher, C.J. (2010). Case Report: Intermittent brachial neuralgia of anterior branch of medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve with mechanical allodynia of 15 months duration. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 7(4), 170-179.
Available (5/28/2016): http://www.unifr.ch/neuro/rouiller/somesthesie/enews2010/e-News%207(4).pdf#page=11
Desfoux, N., Al-Khodairy, A. & Spicher, C.J. (2008). Névralgie dorso-intercostale avec allodynie mécanique: Diminution rapide de douleurs neuropathiques chroniques par rééducation sensitive. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 5(1), 10-32.
Available (5/28/2016): http://www.unifr.ch/neuro/rouiller/somesthesie/enews2008/e-News%205(1).pdf#page=10
Desfoux, N., Fehlmann, P., de Reynier, J.C. & Spicher, C.J. (2009). Névralgie dorso-intercosto-brachiale incessante avec allodynie mécanique : Fait clinique d’une diminution rapide de douleurs neuropathiques chroniques par rééducation sensitive. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 6(3), 105-127.
Available (5/28/2016): http://www.unifr.ch/neuro/rouiller/somesthesie/enews2009/e-News%206(3).pdf#page=18
Duchesne, D. (2014). Efficacité de la méthode de rééducation sensitive de la douleur. Traitement d’une patiente présentant une névralgie crurale incessante de la branche infrapatellaire du nerf saphène avec allodynie mécanique. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 11(2-3), 64-69.
Available (5/28/2016): http://blog.unifr.ch/e-NewsSomatosensoryRehabilitation/wp-content/uploads/e-News_11_2-3.pdf#page=14
Grass, A., Aeschbacher, D., Waldburger, M., Freund, P. & Spicher, C.J. (2008). Rasche Verminderung neuropathischer Schmerzen eines CRPS mit mechanischer Allodynie mittels somatosensorischer Rehabilitation. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 5(2), 69-95.
Available (5/28/2016): http://www.unifr.ch/neuro/rouiller/somesthesie/enews2008/e-News%205(2).pdf#page=23
Landreau, S. (2010). Fait clinique : Névralgie dorso-intercostale incessante avec allodynie mécanique : Début de la diminution des douleurs par la rééducation sensitive. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 7(3), 183-186.
Available (5/28/2016): http://blog.unifr.ch/e-NewsSomatosensoryRehabilitation/wp-content/uploads/Le-News-7_4.pdf#page=24
Langlois, C. (2014). Fait clinique illustrant la disparition d’une allodynie mécanique simple de la branche antérieure du nerf cutané médial de l’avant-bras. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 11(2-3), 73-78.
Available (5/28/2016): http://blog.unifr.ch/e-NewsSomatosensoryRehabilitation/wp-content/uploads/e-News_11_2-3.pdf#page=23
Mathis, F., Degrange, B., Bernier, G. & Spicher, C.J. (2006). Diminution rapide par rééducation sensitive de douleurs neuropathiques chroniques d’une névralgie crurale incessante avec allodynie mécanique. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 3(3), 84-95.
Available (5/28/2016): http://www.unifr.ch/neuro/rouiller/somesthesie/enews2006/e-News%203(3).pdf#page=5
Mathis, F., Degrange, B., Desfoux, N., Sprumont, P, Hecker, E., Rossier, Ph & Spicher, C.J. (2007). Diminution des douleurs neuropathiques périphériques par la rééducation sensitive. Rev Med Suisse, 3(135), 2745-2748.
Available (5/28/2016): http://revue.medhyg.ch/print.php3?sid=32307
Packham, T.L. (2013). Dealing with a Sensitive Issue : Somatosensory Rehabilitation Reduces Allodynia (Case Report). e-News Somatosens Rehab, 10(3), 139-143.
Available (5/28/2016): http://blog.unifr.ch/e-NewsSomatosensoryRehabilitation/wp-content/uploads/Le-News-103.pdf#page=37
Parneix, E. (2015). Traitement d’une allodynie mécanique chronique du membre supérieur dominant. e-News Somatos Rehab, 12(1), 23-28.
Available (5/28/2016): http://blog.unifr.ch/e-NewsSomatosensoryRehabilitation/wp-content/uploads/e-news-12_1.pdf#page=23
Spicher, C.J., Mathis, F., Degrange, B., Freund, P. & Rouiller, E.M. (2008a). Static Mechanical Allodynia is a Paradoxical Painful Hypo-aesthesia: Observations derived from neuropathic pain patients treated with somatosensory rehabilitation. Somatosens Mot Res, 25(1), 77-92.
Available (5/28/2016): http://doc.rero.ch/lm.php?url=1000,43,2,20080507152616-JF/rouiller_sma.pdf
Spicher, C.J., Ribordy, F., Mathis, F., Desfoux, N., Schönenweid, F. & Rouiller, E.M. (2008b). L’allodynie mécanique masque une hypoesthésie: Observations topographiques de 23 patients douloureux neuropathiques chroniques. Doul & Analg, 21, 239-251.
Available (5/28/2016): http://doc.rero.ch/lm.php?url=1000,43,2,20090123161239-ME/rouiller_amm.pdf
Spicher, C., Buchet (- Desfoux), N. & Sprumont, P. (2013). Atlas des territoires cutanés du corps humain : Esthésiologie de 240 branches (2e édition) – Préface : S.W. Carmichael (Mayo Clinic). Montpellier, Paris : Sauramps Médical, 100 pages.
Spicher, C., Quintal, I. & Vittaz, M. (2015). Rééducation sensitive des douleurs neuropathiques (3e édition) – Préface : Prof S. Marchand. Montpellier, Paris : Sauramps Médical.
Spicher, C.J., Fehlmann, P., Maihöfner, C, Sprumont, P., Létourneau, E., Dyer, J.O., Masse, J., López-Solà, M., Maupas, E. & Annoni, J.M (2016). Management Algorithm of Spontaneous Neuropathic Pain and/or Touch-evoked Neuropathic Pain illustrated by prospective observations in clinical practice of 66 chronic Neuropathic Pain Patients. e-News Somatosens Rehab, 13(1), 5-32.
Available (5/28/2016): http://www.neuropain.ch/sites/default/files/e-news/e-news_13_1.pdf#page=5
[1] Unit of Neurophysiology, Department of Medicine, Faculty of Science, University of Fribourg & Somatosensory Rehabilitation Centre ; Clinique Générale; 6, Hans-Geiler Street ; CH - 1700 Fribourg Switzerland ; reeducation.sensitive@cliniquegenerale.ch